Sunday, June 5, 2011

ENUMERATED POWERS

Some say that stating that the Constitution doesn't specifically allow for it, therefore it must not be Constitutional is a failure of logic. But I say hogwash! If you are told, 'You will do these things and nothing more.' then you authorized those things and nothing more. In the constitution we have that specific situation. We have a specific list of duties for the federal government in Article 1 Section 8 (summarized by yours truly):

*To Tax to carry out the list bellow
*To borrow money
*To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, the States, and with the Indians
*To establish Rules on Immigration bankruptcies
*To coin Money, fix the Standard of Weights and Measures;
*To Punish counterfeiting
*To establish Post Offices and Post Roads;
*To enforce patents and copyrights
*To make courts inferior to the supreme Court;
*To enforce maritime and international law
*To declare War
*To maintain the military
*To cal forth the Militia
*To organize, arm, and discipline, the Militia, called to serve actively
*To administer Washington DC and build other federal use facilities
*To make all Laws to do the above

Then to put the cherry on the cake in the 10th amendment specifically states that:

"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."

To me the VERY logical conclusions of those FACTS is that the list of enumerated powers is all there is. Anything else must be handled by the people or the states. Now, as I have said in the past there is some bad case law that we have to deal with, but the constitution itself is pretty clear.

Saturday, June 4, 2011

GENERAL WELFARE CLAUSE IN THE US CONSTITUTION

I really get tired of people pulling the 'general welfare' clause of the constitution.  Its meaning is pretty clear, and it was bad case law that allowed it be used as it is today to do things blatantly unconstitutional.  So, let's explore it for a bit.  It may not change that we have to abide by this case law, but it does explain it.


The term 'general welfare' appears twice in the United States Constitution. Once in the preamble, and once in section 8 which lists the powers of congress.

First the preamble:

“We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.”

SCOTUS has held that - the Preamble to the U.S. Constitution "has never been regarded as the source of any substantive power conferred on the Government of the United States or on any of its Departments"

That's pretty cut and dried. Now for section 8:

There it is in the first power:

“The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall be uniform throughout the United States; “

Thomas Jefferson explained the latter general welfare clause for the United States: “[T]he laying of taxes is the power, and the general welfare the purpose for which the power is to be exercised. They [Congress] are not to lay taxes ad libitum for any purpose they please; but only to pay the debts or provide for the welfare of the Union. In like manner, they are not to do anything they please to provide for the general welfare, but only to lay taxes for that purpose.”

The key point in the Jefferson explanation is - "...provide for the welfare of the Union...." So he pretty much spells it out that it was intended to be used for the welfare of the nation as a whole NOT individuals.

To me that is one of the key points: when the Founders meant individuals they used the term 'the people' when they meant as a nation they used the United States. This would seem in and of itself to to mean that taxation was to be collected for use in the other enumerated powers NOT for individual gains. There shouldn't be any other issue, but the sad fact is that there has been some seriously bad case law that has changed that. However the base dispute goes all the way back to James Madison and Alexander Hamilton.

James Madison advocated for the ratification of the Constitution in The Federalist and at the Virginia ratifying convention upon a narrow construction of the clause, asserting that spending must be at least tangentially tied to one of the other specifically enumerated powers

Alexander Hamilton, only after the Constitution had been ratified, argued for a broad interpretation which viewed spending as an enumerated power Congress could exercise independently to benefit the general welfare, such as to assist national needs in agriculture or education, provided that the spending is general in nature and does not favor any specific section of the country over any other.

I find it interesting that Hamilton espoused his view only after ratification. To me that is enough to dismiss Hamilton, but in several cases. Notably 'US vs Butler' and 'Steward Machine Company v. Davis' the SCOTUS ruled fairly Hamiltonionish (to coin a phrase), but then later in life one of the Justices (citation needed) admitted that he (and hinted that others might have) voted as they did to head off FDR's attempt to pack the court. So they basically destroyed the constitution in order to save the court. Kind of scary, but I think many of the US's problems stem from those bad cases.


Friday, June 3, 2011

DANCER'S HIGH

Now as I sit here typing this with my right foot in a cast and throbbing in pain (thank you modern science for codeine) I am immensely grateful to the gods of dance that they let me have 2 of these this week before I had to stop for a month. One Tuesday and one Wednesday. The one Wednesday especially will be one I relive on my death bed I bet. Both were in practice sessions after lessons at separate classes. My wife and I hadn't taken the classes because we knew I would not be able to finish them due to the cast, but we'd gone to the after class sessions just to be with our people and enjoy ourselves before the forced hiatus. I am of course referring to the perfect dance. The dance that transports you a higher plane of existence.  I don't expect every one to understand this, but my friends who dance will. Hopefully it will inspire some of my non dancing friends to start.

The perfect dance doesn't happen very often, but occasionally everything works just right and you get that perfect moment in dance. It's you, your partner, and the music all becoming one entity that exists in a place not of this world.

I had never understood the concept of a runner's high until the first time this happened to me. It was 20 years ago, and up until then my learning to dance was primarily a way to meet women. One in which I'd had limited success I might add, but I'd stuck with it since I've never been very good at quitting. I can't tell you her name, but she was my instructor's professional partner, we were dancing two step in a now long gone night club in North Austin. From that moment I realized that I could no longer exist without dance.

It was years before I had that experience again, and even now when my health lets me dance regularly it's only an occasional thing, but I still hope for it every time I walk on the floor. I wish I had the words to describe it fully, but I don't. I once heard that every dance was a short relationship, and that's true, but when the perfect dance comes along it's even more intimate. It's as if your souls touch and intertwine with the music and if you could you would exist there forever.

And, it doesn't matter what type of dance. It can be country, ballroom, or as in the case this week my favorite West Coast Swing. So, if you haven't been dancing for a while, or if you've never been, go! It's the only way to fly.

PS – it's times like this that I wish I had more literary talent to describe the feeling so if you don't fully get it don't blame the dance blame the dancer :)

Saturday, May 28, 2011

UNWORTHY

Every once in a while something happens to remind me how unworthy we are of the sacrifices made for us by our soldiers. But would you believe that one of those instances was while shopping this morning? I was going into one of the big box membership stores, I won't say which one other than to say that there's a family in Arkansas that's just a tad bit more wealthy. Anyway, there I was heading into the store with nothing more than my shopping list on my mind, and there they were - JROTC from a local high school. Of course they were there in honor of Memorial Day. As I walked in, and then out when I was done shopping they called attention, and saluted me. Now I'm not special they were doing this for all customers going and coming. But it made me a bit uneasy. I finally figured why.

Here I am a middle aged guy who's offer to serve was declined, and these kids who are in high school and already preparing to defend our country and way of life. With their life if necessary. And, they're saluting me? That is wrong. I am simply unworthy of that honor. If anything I should have been saluting them and thanking them.

Every time I get pessimistic about our nation, this sort of thing happens to me. Here are a bunch of upper income high school kids, and they at age 13 – 18 are already planning for a life of service, and hardship to protect our rights. This was not a poor section of town, and the school in question was not some inner city hell hole that would force kids into this. Indeed this was one of the richer parts of town, and better schools full of kids who's families have money and privilege. And they're going to be the next generation of officers serving our nation with all the hardship and sacrifice that entails. Amazing!  If that doesn't give you hope I don't know what will. So, remember our fallen this weekend. That is what Memorial Day is for, but keep in the back of your head that a new generation stands ready to take up the banner, and move us forward into the future, and take pride in them.

Friday, May 27, 2011

PALIN THE TROJAN HORSE?

It is I, your humble commentator, and amidst Sarah Palin announcing her new tour, and everyone starting to wonder if she's getting ready to jump into the 2012 presidential race I wonder if it's not all a ruse.

I can see very clearly in my mind's eye a group of republicans going to Sarah and proposing a way she can make money selling books and speaking engagements while throwing the democrats off the scent. You see by her merely stepping up her profile she has all the dems in a twidget for one reason or another over the fact that she may be running. Either they are happy because they think they can beat the ditzy broad from Alaska, or they're scared out of their mind that she's about to whup them like they so richly deserve.

You see it doesn't matter to my imaginary republicans, either way they can work in the background, and whoever does become the republican nominee has an open field to run in while all the silly dems are still chasing Sarah who's running up and down the sidelines leading them on a merry chase to nowhere. Then all of a sudden they have less time to go after whoever winds up with the nominee, and Sarah has a couple of extra million to add to her fortune, and has the dems to thank for it.

Which is why I firmly believe that this is all a ruse. Not sure I want it to be true, but my feeling is that she's not running. That all of this is intentionally or not simply providing cover for the republicans to do as they wish for a while.

Thursday, May 5, 2011

MONEY GARDENS

You know the more I think about 'tax the rich' or 'spread the wealth' plans they really annoy me. I have recently begun a small vegetable garden, and even eaten some of the tomatoes I have begun getting. And the other day while tending that garden it hit me, that a business is like a garden on a much longer term and larger scale.


In a garden you get out in spring and work your tail off tilling, fertilizing, planting, weeding, and so on. This is much like a business, in the beginning you work 60 – 80 hours a week or more marketing, funding, selling, manufacturing, hiring, filing taxes, and the myriad of other jobs you have to do to get a start up off the ground.


Then your plants start to come in, and you get to relax. There's still not much fruit, but you can see your work starting to pay off, and occasionally you can step out for a day or so to enjoy life. The plants are starting to do their work, and require just a little input and maintenance from you to keep producing and hopefully growing. In business this means you can step away from your plant or store for a week or so and take the wife on a vacation. But that week is all you can afford, and usually only then once every couple of years or so. But your hours are probably down to say 50 – 60 a week, and you can actually put your children to bed some evenings. If the phone doesn't ring with some calamity.


Finally comes the harvest. The garden has grown all it's going to, and you have start picking and eating the food. THIS is why you did all that work back in spring. You get to eat your own food, grown with you own hands, in your own soil. It's not only useful, it's hugely satisfying on a deeply emotional even for some spiritual level. In business this is where you are established, and you have a good staff that handles most of you day to day stuff for you. You can sort of begin to retire here knowing that you money garden is starting to ripen. But WAIT! Now steps in the government and says you are the winner of life's lottery, and your fru... I mean money has to be spread around to those that did not plant anything and are less 'lucky'.


Now they weren't around when you were breaking your back hoeing the rows, planting the seeds, or lugging water and fertilizer all over the place, but now they want your food? We wouldn't dream of taking a gardeners food like that, and yet we have no problem taking a man's money when he spends a life time growing a business or investing wisely. How is that morally right I ask you.


So next time you hear 'tax the rich' think of your garden, and how mad you would be if the government just came in took your harvest and handed it out to those that watched TV all spring and summer while you were in the yard working, and tell them not just, “No,” but, “Hell no! No fucking way!!!!”


Because that business is that owner's garden, and he deserves every bite of food he gets. And like most gardeners I know I'd bet that he'll be trying to give away the excess rather than let it go to waste. Either by reinvesting in other businesses or through charity. So it will get spread in the owner's way as it should.

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

EDUCATIONAL MONEY

Outrage around homeless mom charged for sending son to better school


The link above is for a Yahoo news story about a homeless lady who's crime was to try to get her children into a good school by using a friend's address. The attitude of the school system can be summed up by a quote from school board president Jack Chiaramonte, "There has to be a penalty for stealing our services."


Well I have a couple of issues with that. The services are not his. They are the property of the tax payer, but let's lay that aside. I'd bet that his attitude would be completely different if the educational money was attached to the child, and not the district. If he had to compete for that money he'd be trying to steal that kid from the other schools, not whining that he had an extra. This is a prime example of how a free market system would produce a better attitude in our educators.


Personally I'd just as soon see the money never be taken from the parents in the first place, all schools be privatized, and the parents just have the freedom to educate their kids as they see fit. Now I'm not naive enough to think that would work either. There are many lazy parents who would just let their kids run wild and be a burden to society forever, but since we can't have my ideal I do think some way to attach the money to the kid would be the best answer.


Which brings us to vouchers. I like the idea of a voucher, then the schools have to compete for the money. Especially if you also allowed the schools to set their prices. At the minimum end of the scale would be the WalMarts of education. Solid basic schools that would educate the majority of students to a decent level, but have very few frills. At the other end you would have the boutiques of eduction. They would charge more, but you and your kids would get more for your time, money, and effort. In between would be the Sears of education. Not Walmart, but not a boutique either. These schools would be a nice happy medium. And of course there would be a nearly infinite number of gradients in between, and as a parent you could pick your school based on your criteria of your kids aptitude, your location, budget, and any other factor you'd care to use.


But for some reason this is considered bad for parents and kids. I'm not sure I get it. Especially when the option is putting the parent in jail and leaving the child an orphan in a lousy school. Exactly how is that good for our children?


PS - The friend who provided the address? Now she's homeless also as she got evicted for her 'crime' of allowing a homeless friend shelter occasionally. Boy, that's compassionate ain't it.